
Insights
Executive Flats Look Cheapest Per Square Metre. Matched, They Cost 8.5% More Than 4-Rooms.
Per square metre, HDB resale prices fall as flats get bigger. That stops at the Executive. Matched on town, remaining lease, storey band and half-year, the 4-room buys space 3.1% cheaper than a 3-room, the 5-room at the same rate, and the Executive 8.5% dearer.
By TRIBE Research · 15 November 2026 · 9 min read
The decision
- Who this is for
- HDB buyers choosing between a 3-room, 4-room, 5-room or Executive in the same town, and Executive owners weighing a sale.
- The question
- Does buying the bigger flat get me space more cheaply?
- The short answer
- Up to a point. Matched on town, remaining lease, storey band and half-year, the 4-room buys space 3.1% cheaper per square metre than the 3-room, and the 5-room costs the same per square metre as the 4-room. The Executive reverses it: 8.5% more per square metre than a 4-room, and dearer in 84% of matched groups. The raw medians say the opposite because Executive flats carry shorter leases.
- Next step
- Before paying up for the Executive, check what 5-room flats of the same remaining lease in that town actually sold for per square metre.
The numbers behind it
- 8.5% more per square metreExecutive against 4-room, matched on town, lease, storey and half-year.
- 3.1% less per square metreThe four-room against the three-room, same matched groups.
- 84% of matched groupsShare of matched groups where the Executive is dearer.
Across 243,867 HDB resale transactions registered between January 2017 and October 2026, the national medians say what a buyer's instinct says. The bigger the flat, the less you pay for each square metre of it. The median Executive sold at $5,065 per square metre. The median 4-room sold at $5,408.
Match the flats on town, remaining lease, storey band and the half-year they sold in, and that ordering inverts. The Executive costs 8.5% more per square metre than a 4-room, and it is the dearer flat in 84% of the matched groups.
The question a buyer on the HDB ladder is actually asking
Almost every upgrade decision gets argued in total price. A 5-room costs this much more than a 4-room, so can we stretch. The more useful question is what the extra space costs per square metre, because that is the part a buyer can compare across flat types and across towns.
The folk answer is that space gets cheaper in bulk. A bigger flat should carry a lower price per square metre, the way a bigger pack of anything carries a lower unit price. The raw medians agree. The matched data agrees too, for three of the four steps on the ladder, and then stops agreeing.
The answer in plain language
Space does get cheaper per square metre as you move up, but only to the 4-room. The 2-room is the most expensive space in the market. Stepping to a 3-room buys space 6.1% cheaper per square metre, and stepping to a 4-room buys it another 3.1% cheaper.
From there the discount runs out. The 5-room costs the same per square metre as the 4-room, within 0.2%. And the Executive costs 8.1% more per square metre than the 5-room, and 8.5% more than the 4-room. The bulk discount does not merely stop at the Executive. It reverses.
The strongest numbers: the ladder, step by step
Each step below compares flats in the same town, the same five-year remaining-lease band, the same three-storey band, sold in the same half-year. The figures are the median change across those matched groups.
| Step up | Price per square metre | Total price | Extra floor area | Matched groups |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2-room to 3-room | −6.1% | +36.2% | +20.5 sqm | 2,197 |
| 3-room to 4-room | −3.1% | +32.9% | +25.5 sqm | 7,982 |
| 4-room to 5-room | +0.2% | +24.4% | +22.6 sqm | 10,860 |
| 5-room to Executive | +8.1% | +27.7% | +22.6 sqm | 4,145 |
Read the first and last columns together. Every step buys roughly the same amount of extra floor area, between 20 and 26 square metres. What changes is the rate the market charges for it.
The direction is consistent, not an artefact of averaging. The 4-room is cheaper per square metre than the 3-room in 68% of matched groups. The 5-room against the 4-room is a coin flip at 49%. The Executive is dearer than the 5-room in 3,481 of 4,145 groups.
Why the raw medians point the wrong way
The unmatched medians rank the Executive as the cheapest space in the HDB market. They do that because Executive flats are old.
| Flat type | Median price per sqm | Median remaining lease | Sales |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2-room | $6,818 | 92 years | 5,141 |
| 3-room | $5,341 | 60 years | 57,841 |
| 4-room | $5,408 | 78 years | 103,612 |
| 5-room | $5,217 | 77 years | 59,719 |
| Executive | $5,065 | 71 years | 17,372 |
HDB built Executive flats in a narrow window. In this dataset their lease-commencement years run from 1976 to 2004, with a median of 1993 and 80.6% falling between 1984 and 1999. The median 4-room sold over the same period commenced in 2000.
That gap is worth money. Within the same town, size band and half-year of sale, a 4-room flat's price per square metre rises 0.97% for every extra year of remaining lease. Seven fewer years of lease is therefore worth something close to 7% of price per square metre, which is roughly the size of the flip between the raw ranking and the matched one.
The 3-room is the mirror image. It looks cheap per square metre on the raw medians, at $5,341, because its median remaining lease is 60 years. Compare flats with the same remaining lease and it is the second most expensive space on the ladder.
The controlled comparison, and what survives it
The matched frame above controls town, lease band, storey band and half-year. The tighter test is to compare flat types inside the same block, in the same half-year, which fixes the address, the age, the build and the lease exactly.
| Step up | Same matched frame | Same block, same half-year |
|---|---|---|
| 3-room to 4-room | −3.1% | −4.8% |
| 4-room to 5-room | +0.2% | −0.2% |
| 5-room to Executive | +8.1% | +6.5% |
The Executive premium survives at 6.5% across 715 blocks that sold both in the same half-year. It also survives changing the matching bands: 8.4% on two-year lease bands, 6.6% on ten-year bands with no storey control.
It is stable across the lease range, which argues against it being a lease artefact that the bands failed to absorb. Against the 5-room it is 6.7% among flats with 80 to 99 years left, 8.2% at 60 to 80 years, and 8.5% at 40 to 60 years.
Nor is it only maisonettes. Split the Executive sales by the dataset's own flat model and every type carries a premium over a matched 5-room: 8.4% for Apartment across 2,689 groups, 10.0% for Maisonette across 2,284, and 4.8% for Premium Apartment across 809.
What this analysis does not prove
It does not prove the Executive is overpriced, or a bad buy. A premium per square metre is what a market pays for a format it cannot buy new, and the dataset cannot separate that from layout, ceiling height or the internal staircase.
The matching holds town, lease band, storey band and half-year. It does not hold renovation, interior condition, orientation, block position, or distance to an MRT station within a town. If Executive blocks sit systematically closer to amenities in a town, part of the premium is location that the town control is too coarse to catch.
These are realised sales only. Flats listed and not sold are invisible here, so the figures describe transactions, not asking prices.
Price per square metre is also not the same as value. A larger flat's extra area can arrive as a corridor or a second living room rather than a usable bedroom, and the dataset cannot tell the difference.
Finally, this is a pattern measured over ten years, not a law. Correlation is not causation, and the 4-room to 5-room step has drifted from +1.2% in 2020 to −0.1% in 2026, which is a reminder that these rates move.
What this means if you are buying or selling
If you are buying and space is the goal, the 4-room and the 5-room are where the market sells it most cheaply. The step between them is the only one on the ladder that charges nothing extra per square metre. In 2026, across 1,405 blocks that sold both, the median 4-room went for $622,500 and the median 5-room for $750,000, a step of $127,000 for about 20 square metres more.
If you are stretching to an Executive, price it as a format premium rather than a volume discount. You are paying roughly 8% more on every square metre, including the ones you would have had in a 5-room, not just on the extra 23.
If you own an Executive and are selling, the island-wide median understates you. The right comparison is 5-room and Executive sales in your own town with a similar remaining lease, which is also the comparison a buyer's agent will run.
All figures are transacted resale prices. They are before buyer's stamp duty, agent fees and legal costs, before any renovation, and they exclude monthly conservancy charges, property tax and financing. A step that looks affordable on price per square metre still has to clear the loan and the cash.
Next step
Comparing a 5-room with an Executive in the same town? Send us the town, the two flat types and the remaining lease. We will pull what each actually sold for per square metre in matched groups, so you can see what the extra space costs rather than guessing from the median. The Resale Price Check does the same lookup on a single block.
For the same exercise on a different HDB price gap, see what a DBSS flat really costs once you match it on age, and how the three-room to four-room step moved once town and vintage were held constant.
Based on 243,867 HDB resale transactions registered between January 2017 and October 2026, published by HDB via data.gov.sg and read on 15 November 2026. November 2026 is a partial month and is excluded. The matched comparison groups sales by town, five-year remaining-lease band, three-storey band and half-year of sale, and keeps only groups containing both flat types being compared. The same-block test additionally fixes block and street. The per-year lease figure is a within-group regression of log price per square metre on remaining lease and storey, across 100,588 four-room sales in 1,733 town, size-band and half-year groups. Figures are transacted resale prices before stamp duty, agent fees, legal fees and renovation, and exclude conservancy charges, property tax and financing. General information, not advice for any particular flat or household.
Your next step
Comparing a 5-room with an Executive in the same town? Send us the town, both flat types and the remaining lease. We will pull what each sold for per square metre in matched groups.
A consultant replies on WhatsApp. No registration, no obligation.
Prefer a personal read on your situation? Arrange a consultation →Keep reading
Next step
TRIBE Research
Written with AI assistance from TRIBE's own data and the public sources listed, then checked against them. General information, not financial advice. How we write
Sources
- Resale flat prices based on registration date, from Jan 2017 onwards · Housing and Development Board, via data.gov.sg · retrieved 15 November 2026
Data as of October 2026.
How TRIBE scores and checks its analysis
Spotted an error, or a figure that has moved since publication? Tell us and we will correct it.
General information only, not financial, investment, legal or tax advice. It does not consider your own circumstances; check your own numbers before you commit.


