Skip to content
TRIBE
The Same $600,000 Buys 51 Years of Lease in Clementi or 90 in Yishun

Insights

The Same $600,000 Buys 51 Years of Lease in Clementi or 90 in Yishun

A composite couple, both 34, have $600,000 to spend on a four-room flat. In 2026 that budget bought a median 51.5 years of lease in Clementi and 89.9 in Yishun, for the same 92 square metres. The mature address costs $431 a month in lease.

By TRIBE Research · 10 November 2026 · 8 min read

Illustrative case. The people are composites, not TRIBE clients; the numbers follow current rules and real transactions.

The decision

Who this is for
A couple with a fixed budget for a four-room resale flat, choosing between a mature town and a newer one
The question
Our budget buys a flat in either town. What are we actually giving up in the mature one?
The short answer
Years. At $580,000 to $620,000 in 2026, the median four-room carried 51.5 years of lease in Clementi and 89.9 in Yishun for the same 92 square metres. The monthly instalment differs by $34. The lease differs by 38.4 years, which is $431 a month of lease over the life of the flat.
Next step
Price your shortlist per remaining year before you choose a town, and decide how many years you actually need.

The numbers behind it

  • 51.5 vs 89.9 years
    Median lease a $580,000 to $620,000 four-room carried in Clementi and in Yishun
  • $431 a month
    Extra lease cost of the Clementi flat at the same price
  • 1.78 times
    Spread in price per remaining year across the 19 towns in that band

A couple, both 34, have about $170,000 of cash and CPF and a $600,000 ceiling for a four-room resale flat. Their shortlist crosses two towns. In 2026 that budget bought a median 51.5 years of lease in Clementi and 89.9 years in Yishun, for 92 and 93 square metres respectively.

The loan is the same in both. The instalment differs by $34 a month. The lease differs by 38.4 years, which priced per year is $431 a month.

The couple is an illustrative composite, not a client. The flats, prices, sizes and leases are real medians from 2026 resale registrations, and every figure below is computed from them.

The decision in front of them

They are not choosing between an expensive flat and a cheap one. Both options cost about $600,000, both are four-room flats of roughly 92 square metres, and both will cost them the same instalment. The usual way this choice gets made is on location, commute and whose parents live where.

What does not get priced is the thing that actually differs. One flat has half a lease left, the other has nine tenths. At a fixed budget in Singapore, the location premium is not paid in dollars. It is paid in years.

The answer in plain language

Measured per year of lease, the Clementi flat costs $11,845 and the Yishun flat $6,673. That is a 1.78 times spread for the same money and the same floor area.

Expressed as a monthly figure over each flat's own remaining lease, the Clementi flat consumes $987 a month of lease and the Yishun flat $556. The $431 difference is 21.1% of the $2,042 instalment they would pay in either town. It is the largest single line item in the choice and it appears nowhere on the loan paperwork.

What $600,000 bought, town by town

All four-room resales registered between January and October 2026 at prices of $580,000 to $620,000, in the 19 towns with at least ten such sales. The price column barely moves, which is the point.

TownSalesMedian priceMedian leaseMedian sizePrice per remaining year
Bukit Merah12$599,94851.0 yrs92 sqm$11,754
Clementi20$610,00051.5 yrs92 sqm$11,845
Ang Mo Kio29$598,88851.8 yrs98 sqm$11,554
Geylang18$601,50052.5 yrs91 sqm$11,457
Tampines134$608,00058.2 yrs104 sqm$10,445
Serangoon32$609,00058.4 yrs91 sqm$10,425
Bedok30$597,00058.5 yrs92 sqm$10,205
Pasir Ris83$608,00066.0 yrs105 sqm$9,212
Hougang112$604,00070.1 yrs100 sqm$8,613
Jurong East23$600,00071.8 yrs92 sqm$8,362
Woodlands128$595,00072.7 yrs101 sqm$8,183
Jurong West55$600,00074.4 yrs93 sqm$8,063
Sengkang155$600,00077.1 yrs93 sqm$7,784
Bukit Batok64$600,08477.6 yrs93 sqm$7,735
Bukit Panjang55$605,00085.7 yrs93 sqm$7,062
Punggol90$604,00085.8 yrs92 sqm$7,044
Sembawang66$600,00088.2 yrs93 sqm$6,802
Choa Chu Kang99$598,00089.1 yrs93 sqm$6,713
Yishun143$600,00089.9 yrs93 sqm$6,673

Tampines is the interesting middle. At $608,000 it gave 58.2 years and 104 square metres, the most space in the band. A buyer who needs the room rather than the decades has a defensible answer there.

Why "same price, same size" is the wrong read

On the two numbers a buyer checks first, these flats are identical. Same budget, same floor area, same flat type, and a price per square foot that differs by a few per cent. Everything that makes them different sits in a field most shortlists never sort by.

It is also why the mature-town option feels like a win. The couple get a central address at a non-central price, and the saving looks like skill. It is not a saving. It is a shorter asset, correctly priced. We tested that pricing across 13 towns this morning: matched by town, size and storey, a sub-62-year four-room sells 29.1% below an 82-year-plus one while giving up 36.6 years, so it costs 19.2% more per remaining year.

The two flats, side by side

Both lines assume a 75% bank loan over 25 years, which is the longest tenure that keeps the higher loan-to-value limit for an HDB flat, and no other property loan. The 2.60% is an illustrative package rate. The 4.00% line is the floor MAS requires a bank to test repayment against.

Clementi, 51.5 yrsYishun, 89.9 yrs
Price$610,000$600,000
Size92 sqm93 sqm
Loan at 75%$457,500$450,000
Cash and CPF$152,500$150,000
Buyer's Stamp Duty$12,900$12,600
Instalment at 2.60%$2,076$2,042
Instalment at 4.00%$2,415$2,375
Price per remaining year$11,845$6,673
Lease consumed per month$987$556

Over the 25-year loan at 2.60%, interest on the Yishun flat is $162,454, and at 4.00% it is $262,580. Those are large numbers and they are the ones buyers argue about. The lease gap is larger. Thirty-eight years at $6,673 a year is $256,000 of lease that the Clementi flat does not come with.

What this does not prove

These are town medians in one price band, not matched pairs. The Clementi sample is 20 sales. Medians pool remaining lease, storey, flat model, renovation and the walk to the station, so no individual flat will match its town's row.

The per-year figures assume the buyer values every year of lease equally, which no buyer does. Years 80 to 90 of a lease are worth less to a 34-year-old than years 1 to 10, and the market agrees: the price of a year of lease is not constant across the curve, and our own estimates of it inside narrow bands are too unstable to publish as a schedule.

Nothing here prices location. A Clementi address carries schools, the commute and the resale demand that goes with them, and this analysis deliberately does not put a number on any of it. It says only what the premium costs in years, so the couple can judge whether the trade is worth it.

Figures exclude legal and agency fees, renovation, property tax, conservancy charges, grants and CPF accrued interest. The 2.60% rate is an assumption, not a quote.

What this means for a real buyer

The couple are 34. The Clementi flat's lease ends when they are 85. That is a flat to live in, not a flat to sell out of, and they should price it as consumption rather than as an asset. The Yishun flat's lease outlasts them by decades, which is only worth paying for if they expect to sell or pass it on.

So the honest version of this decision is a question about horizon, not about value. If they intend to stay for life and the mature address is worth real money to them, the short lease is a reasonable purchase at a reasonable price. If they expect to sell in 15 years, they will be selling a 36-year lease, and flats with under 50 years left were only 2.2% of four-room resales this year.

One more number for the shortlist. Tampines at 58.2 years and 104 square metres costs $10,445 a year. Sengkang at 77.1 years and 93 square metres costs $7,784. The 19 towns in this band are not a line from good to bad. They are a menu of trades, and space, years and address each have a price.

Next step

Put both flats into Compare Two Homes and read the lease line beside the instalment line. Then work out how many years you need: our matched-town analysis of short leases shows where the market already pays you for the years you give up, and where it does not. Send us both blocks and we will rank them per remaining year.


Computed from 21,803 registered HDB resale transactions for January to October 2026, retrieved from data.gov.sg on 10 November 2026. The band covers 1,391 four-room resales priced $580,000 to $620,000; the table shows the 19 towns with at least ten such sales. Instalments assume a 75% loan over 25 years at the stated rates, with no other property loan. Buyer's Stamp Duty is computed on the IRAS residential tiers in force since 15 February 2023. The couple is an illustrative composite, not a client; no client, transaction or quotation here is real. Figures exclude legal and agency fees, renovation, property tax, conservancy charges, grants and CPF accrued interest. General information, not financial advice.

Your next step

Choosing between two flats at the same price? Send us both blocks and the two asking prices. We will set the lease, the size and the cost per remaining year side by side before you decide which one to go for.

A consultant replies on WhatsApp. No registration, no obligation.

Prefer a personal read on your situation? Arrange a consultation →

TRIBE Research

Written with AI assistance from TRIBE's own data and the public sources listed, then checked against them. General information, not financial advice. How we write

Sources

Data as of October 2026.

How TRIBE scores and checks its analysis

Spotted an error, or a figure that has moved since publication? Tell us and we will correct it.

General information only, not financial, investment, legal or tax advice. It does not consider your own circumstances; check your own numbers before you commit.